The most expensive design mistake I've made wasn't hiring a bad firm. It was hiring a good firm for the wrong kind of work.
I've spent nine years on the owner's side of architecture and construction contracts—office, hospitality, mixed-use, mostly in the $2M to $40M range. I've approved somewhere around 60 design contracts over that stretch. Two of them went badly wrong. Not because the firms were incompetent, but because I never checked whether their actual working scope matched my project's actual demands. Now I run a five-minute fit test before every RFP goes out.
Here's the short version, then the two stories that taught me.
The two mismatches that cost me real money
Mismatch #1: Big name, wrong geography (August 2019)
We signed a well-known international firm for a boutique hotel renovation—roughly 40,000 square feet, design fee around $620,000. Their portfolio looked perfect. What I missed: they had almost no experience with the specific local permitting environment, and the project manager assigned to us was splitting time across three time zones.
We went through four rounds of construction-document revisions because of code-interpretation issues that a local firm would've flagged in week one. Eleven weeks of delay. Roughly $95,000 in redesign fees and carrying costs, give or take a few thousand. The design was beautiful. The experience was brutal.
Mismatch #2: Right size, wrong scope (March 2022)
Lesson learned, right? So on a $1.2M restaurant build-out I went the other direction and hired a three-person local studio. Great people, sharp drawings, fair price. But they couldn't coordinate the structural and MEP trades—it just wasn't in their working scope. Six weeks of on-site rework later (ugh, that one still stings), we had a functioning project and I had a new appreciation for the word "coordination."
So the lesson wasn't "hire big" or "hire small." It was: match the firm's actual output capacity to the project's actual coordination load. That's it. That's the whole test.
The three questions I now ask every firm
I don't trust portfolios anymore—everyone's portfolio looks great. I ask three questions on the first call:
- "How many projects of this exact type and scale did you complete in the last 24 months?" Not "similar." Not "related." Exact type and scale. I want to hear specific numbers, not adjectives.
- "Who runs my project day to day, and what else are they handling?" The partner in the pitch deck is rarely the person in the drawings. I want the actual person's name and their current workload.
- "What do you not do?" This is the revealing one. Firms that hesitate on this question are usually about to overpromise.
That third question is where I've learned the most. A firm that says "we don't do structural in-house" or "we don't take projects under a certain size" has just told me exactly where their boundary sits. That's not a weakness. That's the most useful information in the entire conversation.
What 'fit' actually looks like on complex projects
Where this really matters is office-to-residential conversion work—and it's why integrated firms exist in the first place.
Converting a 1980s office tower into apartments isn't a design problem with a construction phase attached. You're dealing with structural load changes, daylight and egress requirements that were never conceived for residential occupancy, MEP systems that need to be rerouted through a floor plate that fought back, and life-safety systems that have to satisfy two very different code books. When architecture, interiors, and construction management sit in the same organization, those conflicts get caught during feasibility—not after the first permit submission.
For context: according to AIA firm survey data, the vast majority of U.S. architecture firms have fewer than 10 employees (Source: AIA Firm Survey Report; verify current figures at aia.org). Most firms physically cannot staff that kind of coordination internally. That's not a knock—it's just arithmetic. It also means that for complex conversions, the integrated model isn't a luxury, it's the difference between catching problems at feasibility and catching them on site.
This is the space Gensler plays in, and it's where the firm makes the most sense: large-scale, multi-discipline projects where architecture, interiors, and construction management need to move as one team. Their office-to-residential conversion work is the clearest example—when a project has that many moving parts, the coordination premium is real money, not marketing.
But their residential work is mostly multifamily and high-rise. If you're renovating a single-family home or running a small boutique renovation, this is probably not the right fit—and honestly, that's fine to say out loud. The firm I trust most is the one that tells me where its strengths end.
When this test doesn't apply
Two honest caveats. First, this test assumes a project with meaningful coordination load—I'd say design fees above roughly $400K or so. For smaller projects, the calculus shifts toward responsiveness and local knowledge, and a well-run small studio often beats a large firm on both. Second, my experience is U.S. and Western Europe only; I can't speak to how these dynamics play out in other markets.
And a small note on something I keep running into: if you search "gensler" expecting information about the SEC, you're thinking of Gary Gensler—a completely different person in a completely different field. Same name, unrelated job. Which is, if you think about it, the whole point of this article. The name on the door tells you nothing. The fit tells you everything.
Pricing and firm data referenced here reflect late 2024 conditions. Verify current numbers before you budget—this stuff moves.